Review: Choreographer Meets Bach, and It’s a Match
MONTCLAIR, N.J. — Monumental and infamously intricate, Bach’s “Goldberg” Variations is a daunting challenge for a pianist — and even more of one for a choreographer. The prospect of trying to match and sustain the invention and complex structure of the score’s Aria and 30 variations is enough to make anyone tighten up. But what’s most wonderful about “New Work for Goldberg Variations,” a collaboration between the pianist Simone Dinnerstein and the choreographer Pam Tanowitz, is the near absence of strain.
Ms. Tanowitz has long been one of the most formally brilliant choreographers around. And “New Work,” which had its local premiere at the Alexander Kasser Theater here as part of the Peak Performances series, makes full use of her formal skills. Bach’s braiding of multiple voices, in canon and in close but not exact imitation, meets a sibling in Tanowitz’s compositional sense. Her seven dancers continually shift in and out of unison, with some joining in or branching off. The stage action sometimes builds to such heady density that a pause in the music comes as a needed chance to catch your breath.
The connections between the choreography and the score are far from fixed. Note to note and section to section, Ms. Tanowitz goes her own way, so that both the movement and its correspondences to the music are unpredictable. At its best, this dynamic feels spontaneous, serendipitous, as if the dancers (and we with them) are surprised by what Ms. Dinnerstein plays. And this semi-independent relationship (especially at the beginnings and endings of sections) has the additional effect of weaving the score’s parts together in a new way. The humble-sounding title accurately announces a rare achievement.
Fans of Ms. Tanowitz’s work might have expected as much. What’s more surprising is the warmth and intimacy here. Some of this surely stems from Ms. Dinnerstein, who plays center stage, barefoot like the dancers, in a free and unorthodox interpretation that by itself is well worth the price of admission. We first hear her in darkness. Then Davison Scandrett’s imaginative (if occasionally attention-stealing) lighting reveals her hands, which throughout the work do a dance themselves, skittering spiderlike up and down the keyboard or floating gracefully above it.
Slowly, the lights dawn on the dancers. As they proceed to move all around Ms. Dinnerstein, their relationship to her is cordial but courteous. Around halfway through the work’s 75 minutes, when one of the dancers first places a hand on the piano, it carries the charge of a first touch on a first date. Later, the dancers sit near Ms. Dinnerstein or even join her on the piano bench, but still she remains slightly apart, in a solitude that we and the dancers seem to share.
The dance vocabulary also contributes to the warmer tone. Alongside Ms. Tanowitz’s usual pulled-up complex coordinations, deriving from Merce Cunningham’s, there’s a softer plainness in simple steps, hand-in-hand folk-dance circles and Isadora Duncan-like Grecian-urn groupings. I don’t think it was only the presence in the cast of the ever-excellent Mark Morris alumna Maile Okamura that put me in mind of Mr. Morris’s dances.
Ms. Tanowitz, though, retains her idiosyncrasy. Shoulders shimmy and legs flick, semi-randomly. Ms. Tanowitz’s resistance to convention can be blatant in a witty way, but her swerves and juxtapositions are rarely timed to provoke a laugh. Her contrary motions and eccentricity generally keep things intriguing, though at the cost of intermittently making you worry if she’s lost her way.
Sometimes, she goes deeper. In one solo, Melissa Toogood, the most amazingly capable and humanly open member of the cast, seems to break down, with springs in her clockwork popping loose.
And in an ensemble bit that returns with the final reprise of the Aria, the dancers, repeatedly bending to one knee, seem to be blown across the stage like autumn leaves by a slow and erratic wind. You can hear that in Ms. Dinnerstein’s playing, but you can see it better thanks to Ms. Tanowitz.
Review: Pam Tanowitz’s Delicate Dance With Bach
By Siobhan BurkeDec. 12, 2019
Her “New Work for Goldberg Variations” shows a balanced, unstrained partnership between choreographer and composer.
Jason Collins in “New Work for Goldberg Variations” at the Joyce Theater. Simone Dinnerstein and her grand piano are centerstage throughout the dance.
Jason Collins in “New Work for Goldberg Variations” at the Joyce Theater. Simone Dinnerstein and her grand piano are centerstage throughout the dance.Andrea Mohin/The New York Times
At this point fans and followers of Pam Tanowitz know: She has had a busy year. With her first commissions for New York City Ballet, the Martha Graham Dance Company, the Paul Taylor Dance Company, the Royal Ballet and more, she has broken through to a new level of visibility after more than two decades of quiet, steady work — much of it no less fascinating than her recent high-profile projects.
To cap off the year, New York audiences get to see her extraordinary “New Work for Goldberg Variations,” a 2017 collaboration with the celebrated pianist Simone Dinnerstein. On Tuesday at the Joyce Theater, her company was missing a dancer — Victor Lozano was out sick — but if this caused any disruptions to the remaining cast of six, it was hard to tell.
When “New Work” had its northeast premiere at Peak Performances in Montclair, N.J., Ms. Tanowitz spoke about the daunting nature of its Bach score. What’s striking, though, is how very undaunted she seems. Even in moments of deference to Ms. Dinnerstein — who sits at a grand piano center stage, like the sun around which the dancers orbit — the choreography meets the music in a balanced, unstrained partnership. Neither needs to prove itself to the other.
With its flurry of arrivals and departures and its dramatic fluctuations of light (designed by Davison Scandrett), the 75-minute work never stays in one place for too long. But it starts slow, with light rising on Ms. Dinnerstein’s hands as they bring the first few notes into existence: a reminder that music, too, comes from the body.
And Ms. Tanowitz treats the piano almost like another body in the space, a useful obstacle that orders the dancers’ elaborate interactions: something to be circled, held onto, crawled under, revered or ignored. Its unavoidable heft matches the often deliberately cumbersome, even goofy quality of her ballet-informed steps, like flat-footed loping, or jumps that resist leaving the ground, or, in the spirit of Merce Cunningham, vexing coordinations of the torso and legs.
The dancers, all of them winning (and flattered by Reid Bartelme and Harriet Jung’s luminous costumes), accept these challenges with curiosity, precision and good-natured resolve. On Tuesday the long-limbed Lindsey Jones was daring and expansive, at times catching herself in the split-second before falling, or so it seemed. The compact Christine Flores stunned with her unshakable balances and fiery leaps.
But as much as Ms. Tanowitz allows each dancer to shine, she also highlights their support of one another, in small, matter-of-fact ways, like a hand extended to help someone up or guide an exit into the wings, whether it’s needed or not. When, after much dispersal, the dancers flock once more around the piano — a reversal of the opening image — their coming together somehow conveys loss and wholeness all at once.
Maybe she has always done this, but since she unveiled her first work for City Ballet in May, Ms. Tanowitz has bowed barefoot, even on the most opulent stages. It might be a sign that regardless of the accolades coming her way, she intends to stay grounded, to keep doing the work.
New Work for Goldberg Variations
Through Sunday at the Joyce Theater, Manhattan; joyce.org
Simone Dinnerstein
Bach from the Piano at Miller Theatre
Cubadisco premia álbum de pianista estadounidense grabado en la isla
La Habana, 26 abr (Prensa Latina) Los organizadores de la Feria Internacional Cubadisco 2019 anunciaron hoy que uno de sus premios internacionales es para el álbum Mozart in Havana, grabación de la pianista estadounidense Simone Dinnerstein.
El fonograma consiste en la interpretación de los conciertos No. 21 en Do mayor, K 467, y No. 23 en La mayor, K 488, del mítico compositor austriaco Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, labor para la que la instrumentista contó con la Orquesta del Lyceum Mozartiano de La Habana.
Mozart in Havana, facturado por el sello Sony Classical, según la crítica especializada podría ser el trabajo más ambicioso de la carrera de Dinnerstein, que probó una vez más que 'la música es capaz de cruzar todas las fronteras culturales y lingüísticas'.
El Premio Internacional Cubadisco 2019 también reconoce la calidad de las placas Cuba linda, de la trompetista holandesa Maite Hontele junto a varios invitados; y La guapería, del cantante español Ton Zenet; Manuel Cesaire. Rapsodias negras y fantasías martiniquesas, de la Orquesta Sinfónica de Martinica; y Vereda tropical de la artista canaria Olga Cerpa.
El anuncio del reconocimiento coincidió con la publicación de los materiales nominados al Premio de la Feria Internacional Cubadisco 2019, la más importante de su tipo en la isla dedicada a reconocer lo mejor de la discografía nacional y que en esta edición celebra los 500 años de la fundación de La Habana.
Con 29 categorías en el concurso optan por el premio los compactos Anvestral Memories Album, del percusionista cubano Yosvany Terry y el pianista francés Baptiste Strotignon, en el apartado Jazz.
En la misma sección están los fonogramas Italuba Big Band, del baterista Horacio 'El Negro' Hernández, y Back to the Sunset, producción del percusionista Dafnis Prieta que se alzó con el Grammy 2018 a Mejor Álbum de Jazz Latino.
Por el premio en diferentes categorías también compiten los álbumes Standars Americanos, del cantautor Pablo Milanés, Lluvia y fuego, del cantante de música popular bailable cubana Isaac Delgado, y La Bandera de mi tierra, de la legendaria agrupación Rumbera Los Muñequitos de Matanzas.
Cubadisco 2019 tendrá lugar en esta ciudad del 18 al 26 de mayo próximo.
Simone Dinnerstein Solo Recital at National Sawdust
Sunday February 24, 7:00 pm - 9:00 pm $34.83
Acclaimed composer Patrick Zimmerli’s Now and Then series juxtaposes music of our time with the groundbreaking works from previous eras that inspired it, illuminating the common ground between past and present and showcasing the ways in which the music of today has its roots in rich and ongoing traditions.
The first concert in this series features chart-topping pianist Simone Dinnerstein playing works by Franz Schubert and Philip Glass. “An artist of strikingly original ideas and irrefutable integrity” (Washington Post), Dinnerstein teases out the commonalities between Schubert’s sentimental miniatures and Glass’s propulsive textures, finding a wellspring of shared inspiration behind both composers’ works.
Some information for National Sawdust....80 North 6 Street, Williamsburg, Brooklyn, Tel. (646) 779-8455, infor@nationalsawdust.org
Brrr...it's cold outside!
Cozy up and enjoy a LIVE STREAM of the Goldberg Variations tonight!
Simone performs a unique arrangement of the work that inspired her debut album with Grammy-nominated chamber orchestra A Far Cry. Simone and A Far Cry worked together to reimagine the Goldbergs, creating unusual textures and sound worlds.
Tonight's performance in Boston is SOLD OUT, but you can watch it live from your corner of the world through the stream. Tune in at 8pm EST!
Simone will be performing at National Sawdust on February 24 as the first performer in Patrick Zimmerli's Now and Then series. The series juxtaposes music of our time with the groundbreaking works from previous eras that inspired it. Simone will perform works by Schubert and Glass, creating a suite that moves seamlessly between the two composers. Read about her December 2018 performance at the Kennedy Center that received rave reviews from the Washington Post: here
"Her intoxicatingly rich, velvety sound always retains agility and translucence. She risks slow tempos that suspend time without sacrificing the musical thread, and when things heat up the room seems ready to burst into flames."
A spellbinding concert from pianist Simone Dinnerstein
Pianist Simone Dinnerstein has a reputation for doing things her way. She began her career on the late side, not with a stack of competition laurels, but with a self-financed recording of Bach’s “Goldberg Variations” in 2007 that promptly went viral. At first glance, the program of her Washington Performing Arts concert at the Kennedy Center on Thursday night seemed an odd juxtaposition of largely repetitive music. There was no intermission (only a brief break halfway through), and Dinnerstein played everything virtually without pause, each piece segueing into the next.
Two early-18th-century pieces by François Couperin bracketed the first half, enfolding Schumann’s “Arabeske” and Philip Glass’s “Mad Rush” from 1979. Then Erik Satie’s enigmatic “Gnossienne No. 3” prefaced the most challenging of Schumann’s piano cycles, “Kreisleriana.”
Dinnerstein’s stage manner is disarmingly unaffected, and once seated at the piano, her concentration becomes riveting. Her intoxicatingly rich, velvety sound always retains agility and translucence. She risks slow tempos that suspend time without sacrificing the musical thread, and when things heat up the room seems ready to burst into flames. Ultimately, it is Dinnerstein’s unreserved identification with every note she plays that makes her performance so spellbinding.
The vast architecture of Glass’s “Mad Rush” was shot through with ever-changing light, creating a hypnotic effect with a delicate symbiosis of the physical and spiritual. The recurring affability in Schumann’s “Arabeske” progressed into anguished yearning. It was in the confiding intimacy of “Kreisleriana,” however, that Dinnerstein’s gifts held their most powerful sway. Secrets of troubles and joys, obsession and aspiration were imparted with rhetorical poise and rhythmic vigor. Schumann’s famous “inner voices” blossomed as psychological necessities.
Dinnerstein is an artist of strikingly original ideas and irrefutable integrity. These attributes, combined with elegance and grace, lend her music-making its captivating beauty.
Simone Dinnerstein
Simone Dinnerstein
This fall, Simone visits Boston's Symphony Hall and
London Symphony Orchestra's St Luke's!
"In a league with any of the great Beethoven pianists of our time." - Philadelphia Inquirer
If you've been waiting to see Simone live, this may be your chance. Performing Glass's Piano Concerto No. 3 as well as new repertoire including Tchaikovsky, Schubert, and a debut by Ellis Ludwig-Leone, this fall brings something for fans new and old.
Tour starts with two performances of Glass's Piano Concerto No. 3 with A Far Cry this week:
Santa Fe, NM at Lensic Performing Arts Center on September 11
Aliso Viejo, CA at Soka Performing Arts Center on September 14
Then Simone hops the pond to perform works by Schubert for a BBC Radio 3 Rush-Hour Concert:
London, UK at Jerwood Hall, LSO St Luke's on September 21
She visits the Waterloo-Cedar Falls Symphony, one of the 12 orchestras that co-commissioned Glass's Piano Concerto No. 3:
Cedar Falls, IA at Gallagher Bluedorn Performing Arts Center on September 29
An excerpt from New Work for Goldberg Variations, her collaboration with Pam Tanowitz Dance, comes to City Center's Fall for Dance:
New York, NY at City Center on October 3 & 4
And finally, Simone's Boston Symphony Hall performance for the Terezin Music Foundation will include a premiere of Sanctuary by Ellis Ludwig-Leone:
Boston, MA at Symphony Hall on October 8
Can't make any of these performances? Grab a pair of over-ear headphones and check out Simone's latest album, Circles: Piano Concertos by Bach + Glass. The album is still receiving fantastic press following its release in May, including this piece from the Boston Globe. Here's a clip of Simone's recent live performance on Philadelphia's WRTI.
Simone Dinnerstein
Simone Dinnerstein and Simon Dinnerstein: A Conversation on the Mysteries of Art and Family,
Simone Dinnerstein
Schubert & Glass at the Miller Theatre
Dear Friends,
For the past two years, I have been touring a recital program that I find particularly thought-provoking and beautiful. The program juxtaposes the music of Franz Schubert (Four Impromptus, Op 90 and the Sonata in Bb, D 960) with music of Philip Glass (Metamorphosis 1 and Etudes No 2, 6, and 16). The Glass pieces are interspersed between the impromptus and before the sonata, effectively creating new suites of music. It continues to fascinate me how this brings out so many unusual commonalities between these two composers. You can hear me playing excerpts from the program and discussing it in an interview with Walter Parker for Vermont Public radio here. The Impromptu No 3 in Gb, Op 90 is featured in the video above, made a few years ago when my son was still shorter than me! You can buy tickets here.
This past week marked the final performances of this season of New Work for Goldberg Variations with Pam Tanowitz Dance at Boston's Institute of Contemporary Art. We were so happy to receive this lovely review from The Boston Globe and also to be featured in The New York Times' Best Dance of 2017.
I hope you have a peaceful and joyful holiday season and an exciting 2018!
Warm wishes,
Simone
Looking for a holiday gift for the music lover in your life?
Buy a copy of Mozart in Havana here.
Or buy tickets to one of my upcoming concerts in 2018!
January 13, 2018 - Boulder, CO
Boulder Philharmonic
Macky Auditorium
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Bach Keyboard Concerto in G minor, BWV 1058
Tickets
January 14, 2018 - Denver, CO
Boulder Philharmonic
Pinnacle Performing Arts Complex
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Bach Keyboard Concerto in G minor, BWV 1058
Tickets
January 18, 2018 - New York, NY
Miller Theatre at Columbia University
Glass Selected Metamorphoses
Schubert Selected Impromptus, Op. 90; Sonata in B-Flat Major, D. 960
Tickets
January 23, 2018 - Winnipeg, Canada
Manitoba Chamber Orchestra
Westminster United Church
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Bach Keyboard Concerto in G minor, BWV 1058
Tickets
January 28, 2018 - Princeton, NJ
Princeton Symphony Orchestra
Richardson Auditorium
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Bach Keyboard Concerto in G minor, BWV 1058
Tickets
February 11, 2018 - Worcester, MA
A Far Cry
Mechanics Hall, Music Worcester
Bach Brandenburg Concerto No. 3, Keyboard Concerto in G Minor
Prokofiev, Visions Fugitives
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Tickets
February 14, 2018 - Palm Beach, FL
A Far Cry
Society of the Four Arts
Bach Brandenburg Concerto No. 3, Keyboard Concerto in G Minor
Prokofiev, Visions Fugitives
Glass Piano Concerto No. 3
Tickets
February 22, 2018 - Kenosha, WI
Carthage College
A.F. Siebert Chapel
Bach Goldberg Variations
Tickets
Simone Dinnerstein
A Childhood visit: Simone Dinnerstein and Solomon Mikowsky
Simone Dinnerstein and Pam Tanowitz’s “New Work for Goldberg Variations”
By Joan Acocella
October 24, 2017 "The New Yorker"
At the opening of Simone Dinnerstein and Pam Tanowitz’s “New Work for Goldberg Variations,” the theatre—the stage, the auditorium—is plunged in utter darkness. What will happen? Before the lights went out, we saw a nice, big Yamaha grand piano in the middle of that stage, but now it seems to be gone, together with everything else in the world. And then you hear—What? Fingers! Ten little fingers, flesh and blood, playing the aria of this piece of music, and making it sound not like the thing that made Glenn Gould (and Simone Dinnerstein) famous but like something normal and human. To the right, as the lights go up a bit, we see some big, tall things. Birch trees? Stonehenge? Ghosts? No. Pam Tanowitz’s dancers.
For the rest of the piece, they will dance around that piano in steps that are both exact and light. They will go up into the air in a perfect pas de chat (Tanowitz loves pas de chat) but land softly, and maybe with a little “I do this all the time” kick. Two dancers will move across the stage in unison, but not quite perfect unison, as if two ducks were walking across a lawn together, with one maybe weaving in and out a bit, or one exiting sooner. The seven dancers’ manner is objective. Once or twice, a dancer will slap her thigh; once, I saw a lift. Occasionally, you realize that some of them have been taking ballet classes for the last twelve years. But they’ve also been in modern-dance classes, and no one hits you over the head with her weightiness. Nothing is pushed.
All the women wear something like the same hairdos: updos, but one in a French twist, one with pinned-up braids, etc. And they all wear variations on the same beautiful costume: pants and tunics of varicolored patches of chiffon with, underneath, a sort of gold-lamé leotard that keeps glinting and gleaming. They look like deluxe insects. And they changed the costumes mid-dance, à la Merce Cunningham. One woman shed her tunic; a few dispensed with their trousers. Maybe the most wonderful asymmetry of all was that, of the seven dancers, six were women and one was a man, and not one of the women ever fought over the man or tried to get his attention.
They felt like a family, and the long piece felt like the experience of a family, with things going this way and that but always coming back to the true center, never leaving you behind. (This is why people love theme-and-variations structure so much.) There were little events. One of the women came in late. Once, a dancer—the excellent Lindsey Jones—sat down on the piano bench with her back to Dinnerstein, and started swinging her legs. But this was not made adorable, or comic, as it might have been. (“What are you doing, sitting on my bench? Can’t you see I’m trying to play the ‘Goldberg Variations’?”) It was just something that happened, and then stopped happening.
The same was true of their facial expressions. With a few exceptions (Melissa Toogood’s insistently ironic smile, Christine Flores’s perkiness), all the dancers kept their features pretty composed, plain, as if they were classical statues. This gave you a chance to appreciate those faces just as faces—Lindsey Jones’s innocent beauty, Maggie Cloud’s elegant nose, Maile Okamura’s dignified impassivity—the way you might in a family.
The dancers—mostly trios, duos, and solos—were not notably subservient to the music. A fast musical passage might get a slow dance, a soft passage a give-’em-your-all dance. Each was a studied, short, sophisticated, relaxed composition. Nobody pretended this was the first time she had done this dance.
These days, with everyone trapezing around the stage, it’s hard to convince people that something modest is marvellous. But the “Goldberg” audience seemed very sorry to see the show end. We had gone a long way with these dancers—seventy-five minutes—and we could have gone longer.
In most new dances, the choreographer chooses the composer. In this “Goldberg,” I have read, it was Dinnerstein who invited Tanowitz. How brilliant of her, despite the great fame of her score, to hold back on the fireworks and choose what she actually needed.
Joan Acocella has written for The New Yorker, mostly on books and dance, since 1992, and became the magazine’s dance critic in 1998. She is the author of, most recently, “Twenty-eight Artists and Two Saints.” Read more »
Review: Choreographer Meets Bach, and It’s a Match
By BRIAN SEIBERTOCT. 20, 2017- The New York Times
MONTCLAIR, N.J. — Monumental and infamously intricate, Bach’s “Goldberg” Variations is a daunting challenge for a pianist — and even more of one for a choreographer. The prospect of trying to match and sustain the invention and complex structure of the score’s Aria and 30 variations is enough to make anyone tighten up. But what’s most wonderful about “New Work for Goldberg Variations,” a collaboration between the pianist Simone Dinnerstein and the choreographer Pam Tanowitz, is the near absence of strain.
Ms. Tanowitz has long been one of the most formally brilliant choreographers around. And “New Work,” which had its local premiere at the Alexander Kasser Theater here as part of the Peak Performances series, makes full use of her formal skills. Bach’s braiding of multiple voices, in canon and in close but not exact imitation, meets a sibling in Tanowitz’s compositional sense. Her seven dancers continually shift in and out of unison, with some joining in or branching off. The stage action sometimes builds to such heady density that a pause in the music comes as a needed chance to catch your breath.
The connections between the choreography and the score are far from fixed. Note to note and section to section, Ms. Tanowitz goes her own way, so that both the movement and its correspondences to the music are unpredictable. At its best, this dynamic feels spontaneous, serendipitous, as if the dancers (and we with them) are surprised by what Ms. Dinnerstein plays. And this semi-independent relationship (especially at the beginnings and endings of sections) has the additional effect of weaving the score’s parts together in a new way. The humble-sounding title accurately announces a rare achievement.
Fans of Ms. Tanowitz’s work might have expected as much. What’s more surprising is the warmth and intimacy here. Some of this surely stems from Ms. Dinnerstein, who plays center stage, barefoot like the dancers, in a free and unorthodox interpretation that by itself is well worth the price of admission. We first hear her in darkness. Then Davison Scandrett’s imaginative (if occasionally attention-stealing) lighting reveals her hands, which throughout the work do a dance themselves, skittering spiderlike up and down the keyboard or floating gracefully above it.
Slowly, the lights dawn on the dancers. As they proceed to move all around Ms. Dinnerstein, their relationship to her is cordial but courteous. Around halfway through the work’s 75 minutes, when one of the dancers first places a hand on the piano, it carries the charge of a first touch on a first date. Later, the dancers sit near Ms. Dinnerstein or even join her on the piano bench, but still she remains slightly apart, in a solitude that we and the dancers seem to share.
The dance vocabulary also contributes to the warmer tone. Alongside Ms. Tanowitz’s usual pulled-up complex coordinations, deriving from Merce Cunningham’s, there’s a softer plainness in simple steps, hand-in-hand folk-dance circles and Isadora Duncan-like Grecian-urn groupings. I don’t think it was only the presence in the cast of the ever-excellent Mark Morris alumna Maile Okamura that put me in mind of Mr. Morris’s dances.
Ms. Tanowitz, though, retains her idiosyncrasy. Shoulders shimmy and legs flick, semi-randomly. Ms. Tanowitz’s resistance to convention can be blatant in a witty way, but her swerves and juxtapositions are rarely timed to provoke a laugh. Her contrary motions and eccentricity generally keep things intriguing, though at the cost of intermittently making you worry if she’s lost her way.
Sometimes, she goes deeper. In one solo, Melissa Toogood, the most amazingly capable and humanly open member of the cast, seems to break down, with springs in her clockwork popping loose.
And in an ensemble bit that returns with the final reprise of the Aria, the dancers, repeatedly bending to one knee, seem to be blown across the stage like autumn leaves by a slow and erratic wind. You can hear that in Ms. Dinnerstein’s playing, but you can see it better thanks to Ms. Tanowitz.
New Work for Goldberg Variations
Through Sunday at the Alexander Kasser Theater, Montclair State University, Montclair, N.J.; 973-655-5112, peakperfs.org.
Who’s Afraid of ‘Goldberg Variations’? Not This Choreographer.
By GIA KOURLASOCT. 13, 2017 - The New York Times
Pam Tanowitz usually begins a dance when she has an idea for one. But her new premiere started differently: Simone Dinnerstein, an acclaimed pianist whose first love was dance, contacted her. They made a date for coffee.
At that meeting, Ms. Dinnerstein brought several of her CDs for Ms. Tanowitz. “Real CDs,” Ms. Tanowitz said approvingly. “I like that. I’m old school.”
Among them was Ms. Dinnerstein’s recording of Bach’s "Goldberg Variations" ,” from 2007.
“I looked at her and said, ‘I’m not doing ‘Goldberg Variations,’ ” Ms. Tanowitz, 47, recalled. “I was scared of the music.” But then she wondered if that reaction — an unequivocal no — was the reason to do it.
The fruits of her decision will be on display this week (Oct. 19-22) when Ms. Tanowitz and Ms. Dinnerstein present their collaboration, “New Work for Goldberg Variations” as part of Peak Performances at Montclair State University in New Jersey. Sinking her choreographic teeth into something so formal and known has turned out to be one of the biggest challenges of Ms. Tanowitz’s career.
Ms. Dinnerstein, 45, wanted to work with a choreographer in order to stretch her own artistry. Ms. Tanowitz has stretched hers without realizing that she would: “I took the gig for one reason, but I’m actually ending up in a different place,” she said.
As usual, intricate steps are bountiful in her choreography for “New Work.” But there is also space and air between them. “This piece has been an exercise in restraint,” she continued. “I’m allowing myself to do things that I haven’t done in the past: to let certain things flow.”
Ms. Tanowitz’s dances brim with inventive footwork and rigorous, often stringent choreography, in which the influence of Merce Cunningham is often apparent, yet the Bach has unleashed a more humane lushness in her approach.
Growing up in New Rochelle, N.Y., Ms. Tanowitz studied modern dance at the Steffi Nossen School of Dance. She was never a member of a major dance company, but when she attended graduate school at Sarah Lawrence College, she met Viola Farber, the former Merce Cunningham dancer, who became a mentor.
“She loved dancing, just dancing,” Ms. Tanowitz said, “And she gave me that love of dancing back.”
Ms. Tanowitz is passionate about dance history, like her mentor was; she frequently includes references to works by an older generation in both ballet and the modern vernacular. That’s another reason she was intimidated by Bach. His music has been used by many choreographers over the years, but most nail-bitingly for her, by Jerome Robbins, whose celebrated “The Goldberg Variations” was made for New York City Ballet in 1971.
“When people say, ‘Don’t worry about the Jerry Robbins,’” Ms. Tanowitz said, choking on a horrified laugh. “I’m like, no — I’m worried about the Jerry Robbins.”
But in watching the Stephen Petronio Company perform Steve Paxton’s “Excerpt From Goldberg Variations” (1986) as part of the company’s Bloodlines series earlier this year, she had a realization: “Not everything’s been done,” she said. “I feel energized in a way that I haven’t in a long time, because I actually see more possibility, not less.”
In many ways, that has to do with Ms. Dinnerstein’s approach to the Bach, one that Ms. Tanowitz described as “holistic.” Her idea to collaborate with a choreographer came from imagining the music through breathing and movement and steps — perhaps not surprising for a musician who discovered the piano through her dance classes. (She studied ballet when she was a child and living in Rome.)
“I try to breathe a lot when I’m playing,” Ms. Dinnerstein said, “and I try to think a lot about singing, or other instruments. Actually any instrument other than the piano. The piano’s such a mechanical instrument that you have to use your imagination to create these breaths, because you don’t need to breathe when you play.”
Aaron Greenwald, the executive director of Duke Performances, which commissioned the piece with Peak Performances, recommended Ms. Tanowitz to Ms. Dinnerstein. After watching one of her programs, Ms. Dinnerstein was struck by the connection between the choreography and the music.
In “New Work,” the dancers — one man and six women, including the stellar veterans Maile Okamura, Melissa Toogood and Netta Yerushalmy — perform around Ms. Dinnerstein’s piano, which is in the center of the stage. As she plays, she can feel the dancers moving. “Playing that piece requires an enormous amount of focus and concentration,” she said. “Without dancers, it’s a hard piece to perform.”
But when they’re running around her, she looks at them. She wants to interact. “I’m trying to have the freedom to play it differently each time so that I can be in dialogue with them,” she said. “At the same time, I can’t lose my place.”
Ms. Dinnerstein laughed: “It’s really complicated because I don’t want to get them confused if I get confused. I want to be solid for them and at the same time I want to be free — and for all of us to be free when I’m playing.”
While Ms. Dinnerstein has been present at many rehearsals, she has also spent time with Ms. Tanowitz in private talking her through the music. At one point, early in the process, Ms. Tanowitz’s confidence wavered; Ms. Dinnerstein said Ms. Tanowitz felt the need to completely understand the music — in both its construction and its history.
“I have similar kinds of fears,” Ms. Dinnerstein said. “I’m not an intellectual musician — I don’t think from the point of a historian or a theoretician, but more in terms of aesthetics. I think that’s how Pam is too. She is extremely smart, but she really listens to her instincts.”
In that moment, Ms. Tanowitz had been intimidated by the sweeping scale of the Goldberg; she feared that she didn’t have enough dancers to express its architecture. But she has come to realize that because the music is so structured, she has more space to express her personality.
“I thought it was going to be the opposite,” she said. “When I have more freedom, I actually feel like I’m covering my tracks more. I have to have more of a mask. I don’t need to do that with the Bach.”
Because it’s so revered, she can be herself. And as far as setting her movement to Bach? “I’ve been fighting against it my whole life,” she said. “Maybe it’s that I have new confidence. I wanted to push against the formal structure of Bach. To me, this feels risky.”
NY Premiere of New Work for Goldberg Variations
New Work for Goldberg Variations, a collaboration with choreographer Pam Tanowitz, just had its world premiere this past weekend at Duke Performances. I am thrilled that we will be bringing it to the NYC metro area coming up on October 19-22 at Peak Performances in Montclair State University. It is worth the trek to New Jersey and I hope to see you there!
Performance Dates And Info
October 19, 2017 - Montclair, NJ
Peak Performances
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info October 20, 2017 - Montclair, NJ
Peak Performances
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info October 21, 2017 - Montclair, NJ
Peak Performances
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info October 22, 2017 - Montclair, NJ
Peak Performances
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info Reviews Of Last Weekend's World Premiere At Duke Performances
"Bach’s score is a well known thing, but here it is a living, breathing thing. Dinnerstein, who has been playing Goldberg for years, treats it generously, giving each note a world unto itself. Through these seven dancers, Tanowitz’s choreography devises its own language, idiosyncratic yet entirely consistent. Gestures live on the cusp of familiarity, and the brilliantly differentiated cast is indefatigable in following the movement to its never-ends."
- Indy Week "When the music came back around to its initial theme, the musician was closely encircled by the dancers, the sense of wholeness and completion was so beautiful that it brought tears of joy. If I were giving out stars, this would be a 10-star event."
- Classical Voice of North Carolina About New Work for Goldberg Variations
The wonderful thing about great music is its sense of potential. Masterpieces contain more than is possible to realize in one performance. That is the beautiful thing that keeps music fresh for me, even though I spend many hours every day living with it. As an interpreter, my goal is not to get a piece of music “right.” That final resting place of a fully and finally satisfying performance is an illusion. Instead my goal is to satisfy some of the potential in the music. By changing one thing, you quickly discover that other things have changed too. Through the accretion of those changes new aspects of the music reveal themselves.
I have been playing the Goldberg Variations for sixteen years. Recently I’ve begun to feel that there is no need to keep the piece solely to the keyboard. Last year I collaborated with some great string players to create a Goldberg Variations for string orchestra and this year I’ve had the joy of working with Pam Tanowitz to create a three dimensional Goldbergs with music and human bodies intertwined. The many voices of the Goldbergs are so vibrant and distinct that it made wonderful sense for them to be embodied.
Pam has been the perfect person to discover a new Goldbergs with dance. She was not interested in a literal illustration of the piece and neither was she interested in a strict metrical response. I was thrilled to discover that she didn’t even want her dancers to count. Instead she has looked for density and irregularity in her work. I find that a lot of discussion about music, whether through historical or harmonic analysis, has the effect of taking music from world of aural abstraction and placing it in something more ordered and prosaic: what kind of trills Bach would have used, for example, or which voice ought to have primacy at any one moment. Pam has ignored all of that and created her own physical world full of its own abstractions.
What a pleasure it has been to escape the solitude of the piano. Instead of experiencing the Goldbergs alone in a room I’ve done it in the company of dancers all of whom have their own response to the music and their own physical discipline that extends beyond ears and fingers. On the first page of the score Bach writes that the variations are written for the refreshment of the spirit. That has been my experience of this collaboration with Pam.
-Simone Dinnerstein
Pam Tanowitz & Simone Dinnerstein New Work for Goldberg Variations Research in 2017
Click photo to view
More New Work for Goldberg Variations Performance Dates
November 15, 2017 - Lafayette, PA
Williams Center for the Arts, Lafayette College
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info December 1, 2017 - Tallahassee, FL
Opening Night Performing Arts, FSU
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info December 2, 2017 - Tallahassee, FL
Opening Night Performing Arts, FSU
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info December 8, 2017 - Boston, MA
Institute of Contemporary Art
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info December 9, 2017 - Boston, MA
Institute of Contemporary Art
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info December 10, 2017 - Boston, MA
Institute of Contemporary Art
New Work for Goldberg Variations
More Info SIMONE DINNERSTEIN AND A FAR CRY at Miller Theater (Sept. 28, 8 p.m.). A Far Cry, a fine chamber orchestra, is a core part of Boston’s musical community, and it makes its Miller Theater debut here with a program of Bach and Philip Glass. The pianist Simone Dinnerstein gives the New York premiere of Mr. Glass’s Piano Concerto No. 3, along with a Bach keyboard concerto. Mr. Glass’s Symphony No. 3 and Bach’s Brandenburg Concerto No. 3 round out the bill.
212-854-7799, millertheatre.com
Simone Dinnerstein
Simone Dinnerstein
Simone Dinnerstein
In the 2017/18 concert season Simone Dinnerstein will be touring a new concerto for piano and string orchestra written for her by Philip Glass. This exciting new work will be performed by a group of co-commissioning orchestras throughout North America and Europe.
WORLD PREMIERE PERFORMANCES
of Philip Glass’s newest work, Piano Concerto No. 3.
SEPT 22nd, 2017 JORDAN HALL
BOSTON, MA
More Info SEPT 23rd, 2017 CONNECTICUT COLLEGE
NEW LONDON, CT
More Info SEPT 28th, 2017 MILLER THEATRE
NEW YORK, NY
More Info Partnering with Dinnerstein to introduce this new composition to the world at the above performances will be the acclaimed chamber orchestra A Far Cry . The concerto will be paired with Bach’s Keyboard Concerto in G Minor, BWV 1058.
More information on additional performances at simonedinnerstein.com
SIMONE DINNERSTEIN
SoundCloud Widget
Sony Classical has just released Mozart in Havana from Simone Dinnerstein. The new album, recorded in Cuba, may be Dinnerstein's most ambitious to date and is a testament to music's ability to cross all cultural and language barriers. The pianist collaborated with the virtuosic Havana Lyceum Orchestra to perform Mozart's Piano Concerto Nos. 21 and 23. In June, the Orchestra will also make their American debut in a series of concerts, the first time an orchestra of this size has traveled to the U.S. from Cuba since the revolution. In one sense, Mozart in Havana is a return to Dinnerstein's origins as a musician. Her connection with Cuba started early with Solomon Mikowsky, a Cuban émigré who became her piano teacher when she was nine. Mikowsky would tell stories of his childhood in Cuba and the country's many musical influences. Dinnerstein recalls, "I learned so much from Solomon, and one thing was that a musical culture is not something you have to be born to but something you can choose."
WRCJ: Dertoit's Chris Felcyn sat down with SD to discuss the new disc. Listen to the attached segment.